MLB The Show 25: How to Make Tons of Stubs
Whether you're a no-money-spent player or just looking to stretch your Stubs further, this guide breaks down the most reliable and profitable methods for building your in-game bankroll.
1. Collections
Collections in Diamond Dynasty are one of the most consistent ways to earn Stubs over time. By locking in cards you've already acquired, you not only complete reward tracks but also accumulate Stubs, packs, and player upgrades.
Steps to Complete Collections:
Go to "Collections" under the "Collect" tab.
Pick a category, such as Starter Collections or Live Series Teams.
Select a specific collection like "Collect Common Players."
Highlight any cards you own that aren't marked "Collected" yet.
Press the "Advance" button to lock them in and earn your reward.
Repeat for all categories you can progress in.
Even if the Stub rewards seem small at first, completing multiple collections can snowball into thousands of MLB 25 Stubs while also unlocking valuable players.
2. Diamond Quest
Diamond Quest is one of the most lucrative game modes for Stub hunters. You can repeatedly earn specific Diamond cards, and since they carry high sell values (often over 4,400 Stubs), selling them on the Marketplace can add up fast.
A well-practiced run in Diamond Quest can produce steady returns, especially if you flip the rewards right away while market demand is high.
3. Conquest
Conquest isn't just about taking over maps, it's a treasure hunt for free rewards. Many maps include goals that directly award Stubs when completed, sometimes without requiring you to play any full games.
You can simulate games to take territories and still claim these Stub bonuses. Combine this with the hidden packs scattered across maps, and Conquest can be a double win: more players for collections and extra MLB The Show 25 Stubs for your wallet.
4. Marketplace Sales
The Marketplace is your best friend for converting unwanted or duplicate cards into Stubs. Selling smartly can maximize your returns, especially if you pay attention to real-time price trends.
How to Sell in the Marketplace:
Open "My Inventory" under the "Collect" tab.
Select the category for the card you want to sell.
Choose the card, then click "View in Market."
Under "Buy/Sell Options," click "Sell."
Either accept the highest current "Sell Now" price or create a "Sell Order" slightly below the lowest "Buy Now" listing for faster turnover.
Even clearing out low-value cards regularly can add up to thousands of extra Stubs over time.
5. Flipping Cards
Flipping is the art of buying cards low and selling them high on the Marketplace. Done correctly, it can generate a steady Stub income. Done carelessly, it can waste time and tie up resources.
Basic Flipping Strategy:
Go to "Marketplace" under the "Shop" tab.
Select MLB Players or Equipment (Gold rarity players are often the best flipping targets).
Look for cards with a large gap between their "Buy Now" (left chart) and "Sell Now" (right chart) prices.
Place a Buy Order just above the current highest "Sell Now" price.
Once your order is filled, list the card with a Sell Order just below the lowest "Buy Now" price.
Adjust pricing if needed until it sells.
Important: The Marketplace charges a 10% tax on sales. To check if a flip is worth it:
Multiply the card's lowest sell price by 0.9 to see your post-tax return.
Compare that number to the highest buy price currently listed.
If there's still a gap, that's your profit margin.
Example: If a card sells for 1,000 Stubs, after tax you earn 900 Stubs. If the highest buy price is 850, you make 50 Stubs profit per flip.
6. Combining Methods for Maximum Profit
The most efficient Stub earners in MLB The Show 25 use a combination of all these strategies. For example:
Run Diamond Quest for quick high-value card drops.
Sell duplicates immediately on the Marketplace.
Lock in needed cards to complete Collections for long-term rewards.
Flip undervalued cards between gameplay sessions.
By rotating between modes and methods, you're never relying on just one source of income, which helps keep your Stubs balance steadily climbing.
7. Tips for Managing Your Stub Balance
Don't Splurge Immediately: Save for big investments instead of blowing Stubs on impulse buys.
Watch Market Trends: Prices fluctuate after roster updates, program drops, and big in-game events.
Sell High, Buy Low: Always think like a trader when moving cards.
Play Programs and Events: Rewards often include Stubs, packs, and players you can sell.
Final Thoughts
You don't have to spend real money to build a competitive Diamond Dynasty team in MLB The Show 25. With consistent effort in Collections, Diamond Quest, Conquest, and the Marketplace, you can accumulate large amounts of MLB The Show 25 Stubs over time.
The key is patience and smart resource management. If you treat your Stubs like an investment and work multiple income streams, you'll always have enough currency to grab the cards you need, enter events, and keep your squad improving all season long.